Public Works is UNISON Scotland's campaign for jobs, services, fair taxation and the Living Wage. This blog will provide news and analysis on the delivery of public services in Scotland. We welcome comments and if you would like to contribute to this blog, please contact Kay Sillars k.sillars@unison.co.uk - For other information on what's happening in UNISON Scotland please visit our website.
Thursday, 24 April 2014
Local Democracy
The commission highlights the following as the key implications from evidence they have received:
· Definite loss of trust and confidence and participation in democracy: disadvantaged communities that need the most representation are least able to participate
· Link between representative and participatory democracy has become hard to bridge because of the gap between the scale of representative institutions and the community base for participation
· Big government and big local government have struggled to address inequalities because they occur at a “granular local community level” big systems also struggle to engage with the diversity of Scotland’s communities because they are so geared to uniformity and standardisation
The Commission believe to move forward:
· Scotland needs to change the way it thinks about democracy
· Strong democracy is both participatory and representative
· Services and decision making must fit communities
· Improving outcomes requires fiscal empowerment
The report makes interesting reading and the focus on democracy and delivering real change in communities rather than local government structures is welcome. It also gives a good overview of how local democracy operates elsewhere. What it also highlights is how uniform local government functions, responsibilities and electoral mechanisms are across Scotland when so many other countries operate very different solutions for example in villages towns and cities.
The focus on resources is also welcome. The report looks not at just funding for local government but at how to resource and empower communities.
There is a lot to think about in this interim report and very useful detail on how others operate local democracy. The hard work is yet to come though: designing and implementing solutions.
There will be a fuller briefing for branches next week.
Tuesday, 15 April 2014
Food inspection changes highlighted
The Guardian ran an excellent lead story last week on the impact EU changes to food inspection could have on food safety. This is an important issue in Scotland as the Food (Scotland) Bill is being considered by Parliament.
They report that our inspectors have issued a grim warning that more infected animals could enter the food chain because of a shakeup in the inspection process which, means some of the millions of animals they reject each year as unfit for human consumption could still reach Our food plates. Quite astonishing in light of the horsemeat scandal.
Figures collected from UK factories show that millions of carcasses carrying parasites such as tapeworm and animals infected with pneumonia, septicaemia, peritonitis and tumours were removed from the food chain by official inspectors between 2012 and 2014.
UNISON's Heather Wakefield, said: "The UK government's agenda will result in food that repulses us being dished up on our plates. Most people do not know that there are a small group of meat inspectors and vets that keep them safe from harmful and repulsive additions to our sausages, Sunday roasts and beef pies. They work in some of the most awful conditions in blood and animal discharges every day. They are always the first to come under attack, not only from the food business operators, but also from our government."
Labour has supported our campaign. Shadow food minister, Huw Irranca-Davies, said: "The government need to explain why they are seeking to weaken consumer protection and the wholesomeness of produce, barely a year after the horsemeat scandal. British consumers will be appalled at any risk of tapeworm, parasitic lungworms and diseased parts of animals ending up on their dinner plates at home, or in hospitals and schools."
The Scottish Parliament's Health Committee has issued a call for evidence on the Bill. UNISON Scotland will be highlighting these concerns to the committee.
Thursday, 3 April 2014
Why regulation matters
Today, we held a meeting of our members who deliver a wide range of regulatory functions. Planners, environmental health, trading standards and meat inspectors ensure that Scotland is a better, safer place to live and work.
Both the UK and Scottish Governments have bought, to varying degrees, the 'red tape' myth. As the OECD has reported, the UK actually has one of the lowest administrative burdens in the developed world. Even business surveys show low levels of concern and very few actual examples of unnecessary regulation. None the less, in Scotland we now have the Regulatory Reform Act, a largely unnecessary and cosmetic piece of legislation, and today we were considering the consultation on a Scottish regulators code of practice.
The code is a high level strategic document which is the right approach as front line staff cannot be expected to juggle with conflicting requirements. However, there is still a concern that the concept of 'regulators as enablers' conflicts with the primary role of ensuring compliance. In some areas, like food safety, compliance should be absolute, whereas in others an enabling approach is possible. More effort is focussed on high risk areas but we should not abandon others. I did like the SEPA enforcement model in the consultation – ‘chancers’ indeed!
The Act introduced the concept of regulators contributing to ‘sustainable economic growth’. While this is an admirable, if vague, ideal, the actions of regulators have a minimal impact on economic growth. Creating an industry around this issue is likely to add to the recording and other burdens staff are already struggling with.
The biggest concern is cuts in staff and resources. As our FoI and survey evidence shows, many areas of regulatory activity are being abandoned as well as training and other forms of support to businesses. In areas like meat inspection, the industry is successfully lobbying for light touch regulation. I for one don’t want to eat food with abscesses, but that’s precisely what I am going to get when meat inspectors are limited to visual inspection of animals. This is something MSPs will need to address when the Food (Scotland) Bill is considered by the Health Committee.
Sensible regulation is something we all take for granted. We assume that someone is checking that the food we eat and the goods we buy are safe. Increasingly, that is simply not the case and as usual it will be a tragedy that causes governments to rethink the merits of light touch regulation.
Tuesday, 1 April 2014
Childcare: Time to Deliver
Another report on childcare shows that the high costs and complexities of the current system need to be tackled urgently if we are to give our children the best start in life. The Family and Childcare Trust 2014 Scottish Childcare report found that less than a quarter of local authorities in Scotland have enough childcare for working parents (the equivalent figure for England is 54%). Costs for that care continue to rise: 4.8% last year. The cost for part-time care for two children is now 22% higher than the average mortgage bill. Charges vary considerably across Scotland: in some areas the difference is as much as £3000.
The Family and Childcare Trust highlight how complex the delivery and funding of childcare is for parents and for providers. There are direct funding streams for what is officially early years education: your free hours for three and four year-olds, the childcare elements of Working Tax Credit, voucher based schemes through employers and then various small schemes through Job Centre Plus or other funding streams through anti-poverty initiatives which fund nurseries and crèches and breakfast clubs for example. Local authorities also provided free or subsidised accommodation to social enterprises offering childcare and while not officially childcare there are a range of sports and social clubs in schools which are in effect after school care.
The shortage of spaces for children is pushing up costs. Costs that mean many women just can’t afford to keep or find jobs: and yes it is still women who largely look after children both paid and unpaid. Getting childcare right offers a real opportunity to reduce gender inequality by reducing the financial penalties for motherhood. Ensuring that childcare workers are properly paid and have a career path will also reduce the gender pay gap.
Local authorities are best placed to address the challenges of childcare. Delivery by local authorities will help simplify and reduce the artificial barriers round the many agencies and complex funding streams currently in place. The artificial eradication/childcare split needs to go. Local authority provision is also the most cost effective route as currently nursery provision in the public sector is 11% cheaper than the private and not-for-profit sectors despite the higher wages and more qualified workforce. They need the funding to expand to meet the needs of the communities they serve.
The debate needs to move on from “hours” to organising the delivery of a proper service to support the development of our children and ensure that work pays for all those involved.
Thursday, 27 March 2014
Great workplaces address absence better than systems
Today, I was speaking at a MacKay Hannah conference on ‘Tackling Absenteeism in the Public Sector in Scotland: Prevention and Health Promotion’.
Angela Cullen from Audit Scotland set the scene from their published report on Scotland's public sector workforce. This showed that the workforce has been cut by 7% since the crash, down to around one in five of the total workforce. Council staff have taken the brunt of cuts. The workforce is ageing significantly with young people the biggest losers, down by 25%. Over one third of staff are over 50 and that is the biggest growth area with potential skill and knowledge risks for public services as they come closer to retirement. They have extracted data on sickness absence from their recent report into a useful new publication on their website
Fred Best from Work 4 Wellbeing made the business case for taking measures to improve wellbeing at work. More than a glossy document and a bowl of fruit! Poor data is a problem with 18% of sickness absence reported as 'other' due to IT system limitations. A key message was the cost of presenteeism that can cost 50% more than absence - £105bn in 2010. Workplace conflict costs UK business £33bn per year, taking 20% of leadership time and losing 370m working days. Investment in wellbeing can save £4 for every £1 spent. Behind these statistics is the real human cost of ill health.
Roddy Duncan from the office of the Chief Medical Officer outlined Scottish Government initiatives to create healthy working lives in a very challenging environment - ageing workforce and austerity cuts. Long term absence is a particular issue with 51% of long term absentees in Scotland being disabled. The healthy work strategy is based on premise that work is good for health and workplaces should promote health and wellbeing of the workforce.
Dame Carol Black's independent review of sickness absence was referenced by several speakers. That emphasises that worklessness is harmful for most people. Equally useful is the work of The Scottish Centre for Healthy Working Lives.
My presentation was on the reality of the ‘sickie culture’ in the Public Sector: policies, support and management. I started by debunking some of the myths about sickness absence in the public sector. It may be cliché that the only certainties in life are death and taxes, but there are others. For me, one is the Daily Mail asking me to respond to the latest CBI claim that public sector workers have a 'sickie culture'.
The main response to the headline data is that the two sectors are not comparable workforces. The public sector is an older workforce with more women and with major occupational differences. For example, staff in the care sector are 45% more likely to be sick. Public sector staff also tend to work in larger organisations with sick pay agreements and better recording systems. One consequence is that public sector staff have more long term sickness absence but less short term absence than in the private sector. Overall, public v private is simply irrelevant to the debate, you need to look at other factors.
We do know that there is greater and growing presenteeism in public sector. A CIPD survey showed 39% in the public sector compared to 26% in the private sector. Unpaid overtime is also more common in the public sector - 1 in 4 compared to 1 in 6 workers in the private sector. All of this is reinforced in a UNISON Scotland survey we published last year.
Instead of a puerile public v private debate we need to focus on positive absence management. This is my list of measures:
• Agreed absence management policies with proper training
• Regular reviews of data at safety Committees
• Less reliance on formulas and triggers
• Measures to facilitate and promote employee health
• Involvement of quality, independent, occupational health professionals
• Minimise workplace stress
• Employee assistance programmes for personal or workplace problems.
• Maintain contact during long-term sickness absence
• Structured return-to-work plan with adequate adjustments and support.
There was some discussion about the new government occupational health assessment scheme. This is right in principle, but I suspect it will become an ATOS style tick box exercise. Sickness absence rules and targets in the public sector can be very similar - chasing short term solutions at the expense of more sustainable long-term solutions. We also need to recognise the impact of later retirement ages on particular occupational groups.
My main message was that if you are serious about tackling absence you need to focus on making workplaces great places to work in. The speaker from Investors in People described this as the soft stuff, but in their view still absolutely vital. A friendly, varied, fair and supportive working environment is more effective than any set of absence management rules.
Monday, 24 March 2014
Fair Pay Fortnight
Wednesday, 19 March 2014
Public sector pay is actually lower than in the private sector
Our response is usually, we are not comparing like with like, similar to my July 2011 briefing in response to an ONS paper and goes as follows:
• The figures exclude other benefits such as bonuses and other perks that are more prevalent in the private sector. The research is based on snapshot in April after the Jan-March bonus season.
• They exclude the self-employed.
• These are UK figures and in England many lower skilled and paid jobs have been outsourced to the private sector.
• The average age of public sector workers is higher and older workers are paid more.
• Public sector workers tend to have higher qualifications. In 2010, some 38% of workers had a degree or equivalent qualification in the public sector, compared with 23% in the private sector. Comparing the pay of these graduates flips the pay gap around, with public sector workers earning 5.7% less than those in the private sector.
• The key to the difference in pay is the higher proportion of higher-paid jobs in the public sector.
• Also within the two sectors, the gap between the highest earners - in the top 5% - and the lowest 5% of earners is greater in the private sector than in the public sector. This shows that public sector pay is fairer than the private sector.
Helpfully, you don’t have to take our word for this today. There is an interesting analysis of pay data by Professor Graham Cookson in ‘The Conversation’ hard evidence series. He makes similar arguments and adds the impact of working for large organisations that tend to pay higher wages. The public sector workforce is concentrated in larger organisations.
He concludes: “So who earns more? What is clear is that personal and job characteristics are far more important than whether you work in the public or private sector. Yet having controlled for all of these factors, the evidence points towards a small pay gap in favour of the private sector.”
So if you get any calls on this issue today – answers as above.


